← Main Menu  |  Book Contents  |  ← Chapter 1  |  Chapter 2  |  Chapter 3 →

The Rise and Fall Of The NEW Four Seasons 1966 to 1977

Chapter 2 — I’m Gonna Change

In our last Chapter I had told [with Charlie Calello's help] how, from 1964 to 1965 the Four Season's sound developed after the song 'Dawn'. I asked how, in 1966, the existing 3 members of the Four Seasons, now with Joe Long replacing temporary stand-in Charlie Calello, continued the groups work in early 1966.

Well during that year they came up with four top 20 hits on the Billboard Chart as Bob Gaudio [working with new arranger Artie Schroeck] adapted their 'formula' based songs and productions from 1964 and 65 in competition with changes to music markets and notwithstanding Frankie Valli's attempts at a 'solo' hit continued the battle for a regular place high on the charts. As Charlie Calello recalls in 2023...."The real Four Seasons 'production team' through all the hits period were Crewe-Gaudio-Linzer-Randel and me'. It was a case of 'how to survive', if you were responding to the times and would you keep the formula or change?" That is clear and once Charlie, and then Denny and Sandy departed after their early 1966 success with 'Opus 17’(Don't Worry 'Bout Me), it was Crewe-Gaudio-Schroeck who had to find a masterpiece to re-establish their direction.

'I've Got You Under My Skin' was that masterpiece and the FULL formula of their sound had grabbed their fans attention once again. It was a creative piece re-working a classic song with all of the Four Seasons 'formula' making it a solid hit. [Billboard #9 (#6 in Record World)]. Would this re-build the success through 1966 and 67 after the loss of the key songwriters and arranger?

1966 in retrospect was the year in the 1960s of huge change in music and in the case of the Four Seasons in their 'team' and their LIVE act. With a catalogue of hits they were now in demand nationally in the USA notwithstanding the 'British Invasion' of UK groups and artists. They were still relevant with a catalogue better than most to perform LIVE:- and an outstanding lead singer.

'Rock N Roll -- year by year, by Crampton and Rees summarises happenings...."Rock musicians behaved badly and pop music looked trite, innocent and even irrelevant by comparison. While guerrilla war raged in Vietnam, the new counterculture took full shape, and rock became a social force and a weapon in a cultural war. Despite the drug induced haze, the year was one of creative ferment and growing musical sophistication. The Beatles epic 'Sgt Pepper's Lonely Heart Club Band' had a seismic effect. On hearing it Brian Wilson abandoned the Beach Boys album he was working on. The Beatles masterpiece raised the creative bar to a previously unheard level -- some would argue it has not been matched." As George Martin says of the Sgt Pepper album..."As well as changing the way pop music was viewed, it changed the entire nature of the recording game." By now the creation of those 3 minute gems had reached a key point as the technology of recording and the vinyl markets had reached a major change with the move to STEREO albums as never before. Technology was about to change the direction of the music industry. By 1967 Studios like Mirasound where Bob Crewe recorded his sessions with Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons had installed 16 track machines which made a huge difference to working methods over 8 track.

With Philips cashing in on their past hits no 'new' albums from the group would arise until May 67 due, in part, to touring and the changing approach to songwriting and recording.

With the August 1966 release of 'Revolver', the advantages The Beatles had over everyone was clear. No longer a touring band, their output had been studio based for a year and there were now three prolific songwriting Beatles, [and 4 vocalists] and producer George Martin and his team at Abbey Road Studios were breaking new ground. A key production technique that the band began using was automatic double tracking (ADT), which EMI engineer Ken Townsend invented on 6 April. This technique employed two linked tape recorders to automatically create a doubled vocal track. The standard method had been to double the vocal by singing the same piece twice onto a multitrack tape, a task Lennon particularly disliked. The Beatles were reportedly delighted with the invention, and used it extensively on 'Revolver'. In 2013, Entertainment Weekly named 'Revolver' the greatest album in history. The same year, after the British Phonographic Industry changed their sales award rules, the album was declared as having gone platinum. In retrospect, could anyone have competed.?

By comparison, the Four Seasons were struggling to find songs and song-writers as Bob Gaudio continued to tour with the band. They still spent a 'few days before recording sessions rehearsing all their new songs', then they 'select the best gems for their singles', according to a 1967 article and the main 'instrument' of the groups sound was still and would remain Frankie Valli's amazing vocal. He had always carried the group and his ambitions for himself and the 'partnership' [he had forged] with Bob Gaudio was now more focused on a 'hit' as Frankie Valli rather than the continuation of the Four Seasons 'falsetto' laced songs.

This Chapter explores the ability to generate hit 45s by the Four Seasons with Crewe-Gaudio producing [which was still a strong formula based process] and their ability to change and adapt. 'Tell It To The Rain' b/w 'Show Girl' [40412] was released on 21st November 1966 and showed this skill as it reached # 10 on the Billboard Chart. An amazing run of 45 hits was still going. It also captured UK ears at # 37. Even with a top ten hit in November 1965 with 'Tell It To The Rain' we may have thought The Four Seasons would have been wondering how to keep their sound and hits going as 1967 opened in a rapidly changing music scene.

The latest Re-mix in my 'series' Changing the Sound of The Four Seasons' in 2025 focuses on this tremendous arrangement from November 1966. It once again aims to create a truly balanced but dynamic sound-stage using AI to place instruments and backing from the dire STEREO [IMHO] we have had to date.[Click Image to hear]

With the arrival of the Vee-Jay Masters [upon their bankruptcy in August 1966 ] and such a successful Philips career the record buying public were bombarded with 're-issue' albums and Greatest Hits collections by the group in 1966 as they and Philips cashed in. But music was changing and revolutionising the concept of the album as a set of 12 tracks. Motown's roster of artists were dominating the singles charts and the Four Seasons had lost 4 major team members. So they just changed the sound incrementally with more brass and strings to reflect other studio production techniques with 8 track recording and moved their sound on but not in a revolutionary way as The Beatles had done with 'Revolver'. Frankie Valli admitted in interview somewhat surprisingly during the 1970s that they never felt the need to 'compete'.

Bob Crewe and Bob Gaudio however did make efforts to change the groups sound and style of song and did achieve major change as Bob Gaudio turned to Peggy Farina [formerly of The Angels] to help him with a song that would become and remain 'legendary'. 'Beggin' was recorded in January 1967 and released on 8th February c/w 'Dody'[ an edgy r'n'b style song left over from the late 1965 sessions with Charlie Calello]. 'Beggin' achieved a creditable #16 (#12 in Cash Box) and the 45 [Philips 40433] achieved # 16 on the Billboard Chart but didn't chart in the UK although in later years it became a popular Northern Soul dance club hit and would evolve into a mega 're-mix' European club hit in 2007 and has gone on to be 'covered' by rock groups and in the 21st Century recognised as a legendary dance track on the club scene across Europe

But back then this was all to come. Everything would change in April 1967 as Bob Crewe and Bob Gaudio brought Frankie Valli to the right song at the right time. A song for ‘him’. The journey from his first 1965 and 1966 efforts as a 'Solo' artist are worth documenting as the album of that title appeared in June 1967. The roots of this album are firmly set in 1965 and Frankie Valli's desire to forge a 'solo' career for himself. With Philips reluctant to have anything disrupt the hit making Four Seasons Bob Crewe took him to [we believe] Atlantic Studios in June 1965 with a strong Crewe-Gaudio composition. The recording would not be registered till 27th July 1965 and Crewe eventually got it released in September on the Smash Label [S1995] 'The Sun Ain't Gonna Shine (Anymore)' b/w 'This Is Goodbye'. Its modest # 128 on the Billboard Chart was disappointing but even though in the throws of recording and touring with the Four Seasons Frankie wanted to try again and the next time would be with an upbeat song penned by Bob Crewe with arranger Charlie Calello. Possibly again at Atlantic Studios in November 1965, this time the Four Seasons backed him on '(You're Gonna)Hurt Yourself' [Smash S2015 and they performed the 'B' side instrumental 'Night Hawk']. Registered on 30th November 1965 these tracks saw release on Smash S2105 in December 1965 achieving a creditable # 39 on the Billboard Chart.

From early 1966 [after Charlie Calello's departure to Columbia Records] Bob Crewe was working with the more 'soul' focused Herb Bernstein as arranger and a call to sessions singers and some former members of 'The Angels'[Bernadette Carrol, Peggy [Farina] Santaglia, Denise Ferri - today known as 'The Jersey Girls'] for backing vocals, the two sides recorded would become classics. 'You're Ready Now' b/w 'Cry For Me' [SMASH S-2037] was released in April 1966 and achieved a disappointing # 112 on the Billboard Chart ("Cry For Me" was 104 on Cashbox charts) The success of 'You're Ready Now' on a false SMASH “bootleg 45 “ release in 1969 on the Northern Soul Club circuit however would bring its re-release by Philips in November 1970 achieving # 11 in the UK charts and produced The Four Seasons first UK tour [1971] since 1963, where they performed the song 'live' [we believe] for the first time. [but more re that in later Chapters]. As Frankie Valli has commented many times, quality songs and performances will always find success with the right audience at the right time.

Clearly by late 1966 and the relative popularity of the SMASH Label releases [although little promotion], Philips began to think a 'solo' hit might be possible and in October they released Frankie Valli's first 'solo' track on their label, 'The Proud One' b/w 'Ivy'. Released on 6th October, the 'A' side again featured 'The Jersey Girls' on backing whilst the 'B' side was a 'Randell-Linzer'' song which, according to Denny Randell was recorded at the 'Opus 17' session back in the Spring. We suspect the 'A' side too was from the earlier 'You're Ready Now'/'Cry To Me' session back in March with Herb Bernstein again the arranger. 'The Proud One' a Crewe-Gaudio composition achieved a creditable # 68 on the Billboard Chart and would become a Hot 100 Hit again [# 22] when covered by The Osmonds in 1975.

But still by the end of 1967 there was no album to promote what would become an awesome career for Frankie Valli as a 'solo' artist. Until that is his next single release achieved a # 2 spot on the Billboard Chart and would become Crewe-Gaudio's most famous composition: and Frankie Valli’s favourite song. The tale of how the Roostertail Restaurant performance in Detroit launched the climb for this hit is told in the 'Jersey Boys' Stage Show and film. 'Can't Take My Eyes Off You' was recorded at Mirasound in February 1967 arranged by Artie Schroeck and registered 7th April, it was coupled with 'The Trouble With Me'[Philips 40446]. The sessions were captured in a catalogue of colour photographs illustrating Bob Crewe's amazing Studio 'persona' by sound engineer George Schowerer. The 'B' side arranged by Charles Calello must have been recorded earlier in 1965 as he was still at Columbia Records till June 1967. The sessions were captured by George Schowerer – the Sound Engineer and make a fantastic and natural montage of Crewe and Valli working together.

Rare, unstaged moments from the ‘Can’t Take My Eyes Off You’ and ‘C’mon Marianne’ sessions at Mirasound – photos by George Schowerer, Sound Engineer

With such an awesome song [recorded since by many dozens of artists] an album had to follow and the 'SOLO' album went into production with recordings in April, May and June 1967 for immediate release in order to cash in on the single rapidly climbing up the charts. The previous 45 sides were added but with a new recording of 'The Sun Ain't Gonna Shine (Anymore)' in a more polished production. The album only contained two tracks 'My Funny Valentine’ and 'Secret Love' that did not originate on MONO singles. Later in the year, Valli was nominated for two NARAS grammy awards as a single artist. The 'solo' success he always wanted had arrived.

Larry Brown and Ray Bloodworth with Bob Crewe

On a roll now, Bob Gaudio took the Larry Russell Brown-Raymond Bloodworth [a duo writing and performing with Bob Crewe as the 'Distant Cousins'] composition, 'C'mon Marianne' and using the old formula returned to a falsetto-laced Four Seasons classic sounding single. Bob Crewe's production in the early summer had achieved two top ten records from the group. This was just what Philips and the fans wanted. It was released on 22nd May 1967 [Philips 40460] rising to # 9 on the Billboard Chart. Backed with another 'left-over' from the 'Working My Way Back To You' sessions again arranged by Charles Calello, 'Let's Ride Again' was perhaps a style more suitably progressive for 1967. Although recorded at Mirasound on 16 track, the 'A' side of the 45 has added 'echo' from the Bell Studio's echo chamber that Bob Crewe used to create the unique MONO Mix.

It is also no surprise that riding high Philips thought it might score big with a title of 'New Gold Hits' for a quickly assembled 'Four Seasons' album in mid 1967. It was in fact a gathering of the hit 45s including the two 1965 session 'left-overs' and a few April 1967 session songs, so although this was clearly a ‘misnomer’, it achieved # 37 in the album charts and to many fans is one of their best 60s albums. The variety of song writers and styles possibly gives it such popularity. It also included, however, another 'Wonder Who' label credit which would return in July 1967 for a third single, 'The Lonesome Road' [40471]. This was a sound they needed to lose.

'New Gold Hits' was registered with Philips on 4th May 1967 and packaged like a Greatest Hits follow up and an attempt by Philips to "cash in" on the success of 'Gold Vault of Hits', Volumes 1 and 2. So when it came out the average consumer would look at the contents and expect to see 12 familiar titles which they were not, in fact some of the songs had not been issued as singles yet.......and therefore couldn't have been "Gold". The liner notes prove this point by quoting "Add to this LP their original "Gold Vault of Hits" and their equally successful "Second Vault of Golden Hits" and you have a greater store of wealth than Fort Knox." So consumers were being told it was Gold Vault Vol 3, which it was not.

The catchy track "The Puppet Song" was intended for the group to enter as their choice for an Italian Song Festival in the summer of 1967 but that never materialised. In addition, 'I'm Gonna Change', however, was a 'changing sound' by Frankie and the group with no 'falsetto'.

Mike Petrillo with Valli Gaudio and Crewe

It was written by long-standing friends Mike Petrillo and Chubby Cefillo. Mike Petrillo, another 'Belleville boy' along with his writing partner Chubby Cifelli and others wrote several great songs for the Seasons during the 1960s - most prominently "Tell It To The Rain" as well as" I'm Gonna Change"[in 1966], "Pity", "Sundown"[1965] "Electric Stories" [1968]and "Heartaches and Raindrops" [1970] and the Frankie solo's "Expression Of Love" and the memorable ballad "Fox In A Bush"[1968]--- truly quality over quantity! Back in the late 1950s Mike had played in a jazz band with Bob Gaudio and Joe Pesci and helped Joe recruit Bob to the 4 Lovers; he played sax on some 4 Season records and did some arranging for Bob Crewe prior to Charlie Calello joining the production team back in 1962.

The uptempo, driving beat album song "I'm Gonna Change" [Here is the 2025 DES Re-Master] would also become a classic dance tune on the U.K. Northern Soul club circuit during the early 1970s. It was worthy of a single release but Philips missed the boat and it was covered by 'The Velours' with a stolen arrangement but no chart success.......but for both artists the song would keep their reputation going in the UK during the early 1970s in the UK club circuit. As the album's opening track it set the diverse style for this favourite album for many.

But just as Philips were celebrating a # 37 album chart success, the explosive music world of 1967 came up with the iconic album of that or any decade since......'Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band' by The Beatles released on 1st June 1967. The album of a 'kaleidascope' of music styles and experimentation sold 250,000 copies in the first week on sale in the UK, half a million within a month and 2.5 m within 3 months of release in the USA. [Sir] George Martin said in 1994, in the 'Summer Of Love -- The Making Of Sgt Pepper'...."it was a musical fragmentation grenade, exploding with a force that is still being felt. It grabbed the world of pop music by the scruff of the neck, shook it hard, and left it to wander off, dizzy but wagging its tail. As well as changing the way pop music was viewed, it changed the entire nature of the recording game -- for keeps. Nothing even remotely like Pepper had been heard before. It came at a time when people were thirsty for something new, but still its newness caught them by surprise......it expressed perfectly a feeling that was very much in the air at the time: that everything and anything was up for grabs."

The influence of change was having an impact on Bob Gaudio though and his regular visits to the Bitter End 'underground' club in Greenwich Village in 1966 would lead to an idea for a major consolidation of a 'changed' Four Seasons which would emerge in the last years of the 1960s.

Recordings for the follow-up single to 'Can't Take My Eyes Off You' and this album began in June 1967 with the notable change that Charles Calello returned from Columbia Records, while Artie Schroeck took a temporary sabbatical. The resulting single 'I Make A Fool Of Myself' b/w' September Rain'[Philips 40484] was released on 10th August 1967. It used a similar formula to the previous Top Ten Hit and achieved # 18 on the Billboard Chart.

As for the Four Seasons in late 1967 and the success of 'C'Mon Marriane' [NEW 2025 mix can be heard here] a top ten hit again and their 'old sound' back [as well as Frankie Valli 'solo' hitting the top ten] September 1967 brought another 45 singles market song. The group had found problems with distortion recording at Stea-Philips in late 1965 and had based themselves at Mirasound since. They recorded with Bob Crewe's long time Sound Engineer George Schowerer, in September at Mirasound Studios and released on 9th October 1967, 'Watch The Flowers Grow' b/w 'Raven' [ Philips 40490]. A creditable # 30 on a noticeably changing Billboard Chart with a 'flower-power' psychedelic arrangement it was an attempt to be innovative but with essentially the same sound.

Frankie Valli at the controls – Mirasound Studio 1967 – Photos courtesy of George Schowerer – Sound Engineer

Again in December 1967 Bob Gaudio would once again try the 're-worked song' approach in a Four Seasons style with 'Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow' [the Goffin-King 'Shirelles' classic] re-arranged in a totally original way. Registered with Philips on 31st January 1968 it was released on 8th February b/w 'Around And Around' and reached # 24 on the Billboard Chart. This was the final use of their 'traditional' falsetto based formula for some time to come.

Sessions through the rest of 1967 resulted in the 12 tracks for the album FRANKIE VALLI -- TIMELESS [STEREO ONLY - Philips PHS600274] but not released until June 1968 and a year 'lost' in many ways as it only reached No. 176. It included the single 'September Rain (Here Comes The Rain)' but not 'I Make A Fool Of Myself'. A planned single 'Donnybrook' b/w 'My Funny Valentine' designated Philips 40500 was never released in the USA and '’To Give' was issued instead. However, it did come out in Canada with the same number in January, 1968. Only acetate stereo 45 rpm A&R copies are known to exist of the non-released 40500.

The intense 'To Give' b/w 'Watch Where You Walk' [Philips 40510] was the next 45 release on 6th December 1967 which received Radio and TV airplay and reached # 29 on the Billboard Chart.

In order to further promote two Philips singles ('To Give/Watch Where You Walk' and Paul Mauriat's 'Love is Blue/Alone In The World'), the company issued a two promo singles set with fold-open sleeve with photos of the artists and chart positions up to January 20th, 1968. It worked and 'To Give' climbed further up the charts. The album featured a nice movable clock-like design inserted in the front cover of the sleeve but overall achieved a very poor album chart placing. The album sessions in 1968 according to Bill Inglot also included another unreleased track of a very unique arrangement of the classic 'Stranger In Paradise' which saw release in 2023 for the first time.[and can be heard here]

The success on ' Can't Take My Eyes Off You' was the solo success Frankie Valli dreamed of and many today believe that the pursuit of Valli's solo career damaged the groups identity and sound. This period was highly criticised in a Billboard's assessment in 2000 of the period covered in these late 60s Chapters......."Without an album masterpiece for critics to latch onto, they are condemned as a singles act, albeit one of the best and most popular in music history. As might be expected, both the Four Seasons' massive success and their career mis-steps were engendered by who they were as people. There was no Four Seasons concept album to compare with Pet Sounds or Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band during the mid-'60s; indeed, at a time when most popular recording artists released two new albums a year, there was no new Four Seasons LP at all (at least, none billed as such) between the appearance of Working My Way Back to You (in January 1966) apart from New Gold Hits(May 1967)... until The Genuine Imitation Life Gazette(Jan 1969) a full three years later. The latter was Gaudio's belated entry in the concept-album sweepstakes, and some revisionist critics have ranked it as one of the best. But at the time of its appearance, it was too little, too late. As a result, the Four Seasons' status as album artists today ranks far below that of their peers, and their critical standing has suffered accordingly."

Charles Calello's views in conversations on this period are indicative of the loss of the 'brand' they had created that would lock them into being an 'oldies' touring act for the future years till their resurgence....."By the time the Beatles came along, 'the art of the arranger', that was a window that was closing. The records were now being made by groups, by kids in the studio throwing them together, working on them, getting high and putting things together. And that became part of what was listened to. And although we continued to be successful, we continued to work and have success, we were part of the small window. We weren't part of the big window. So although our audiences were there, in my lifetime I must have been responsible for being a part of at least three, four hundred million records that have been sold, but from the Seasons standpoint, if you looked at Frankie's dress and you looked at the way Frank Sinatra dressed, it was similar. Now if he looked like Bon Jovi for example, Bon Jovi grew up after all the stuff was over and he became part of the culture. You know, he actually looks like he belongs there. The 4 Seasons put Nero suits on and had goatees. You know it's funny, when you go see a band, I don't know if you went to see the Eagles tour when they got together again, the same audience that went to see them when they had jeans and work shirts on were the same people that went to see them, except that they had BMW's. When you go to see the 4 Seasons, the same people that went to see the 4 Seasons as kids are the same people that go to see them today. They still have the polyester pants, the goatees, the slick black hair. The people always look the same. So the audience that they appealed to, the mass audience, you know I'm not talking about special individuals that really appreciated the music, the mass audience was limited in scope into the overall scheme of things."

An out of place image perhaps for 1967 as Charles Calello comments

Whilst I put the point to him that no band could universally appeal beyond their 'hit window' ...... "That's true except that if you're making Cola and you know that 80% of the people drink Cola and only 20% of the people drink ginger ale, and you're making ginger ale, you're only going to sell to that 20%. So what happened was, using that same analogy, the 4 Seasons were still making ginger ale when the entire world was involved in making Cola. But still with all of that, look at the success they had during the 60s " and how it would be too late to change their 'brand'

Perhaps it was music's changes and a maturing audience that the group were losing touch with. But being who they were and their New Jersey background [and connections] and Philips perception would it be too late to change their 'brand' and to see they had lost their way? Changing would have consequences that would take several years to recover from with a completely different sound. It was a turning point for 'The Four Seasons'

References:'Rock N Roll -- year by year, by Crampton and Rees: Summer Of Love -- The Making Of Sgt Pepper' by [Sir] George Martin: Billboard Magazine 2000: Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletters: Special thanks for contributions to: Charles Calello: George Schowerer: George Ingram: